How to choose a garage or mechanic
A practical checklist for comparing garage or mechanic credentials, insurance, evidence, quotes and questions.
Loading page
Loading page
A practical checklist for comparing garage or mechanic credentials, insurance, evidence, quotes and questions.
Choose for the actual work, not the loudest badge or lowest headline price. A service is scheduled maintenance; a repair addresses a fault. Interim, full and major service labels are not legally standardised, so the actual checklist matters more than the name.
Write a short brief covering the symptom or outcome, timing, postcode, access, known risks and relevant photographs. State what you do not know. Share the same information with each provider so that their scope and price can be compared.
Confirm the legal or trading name, a usable address and telephone number, and who will attend. Check that the payment name and paperwork relate sensibly to the business. An online profile, advert or directory entry is a starting point, not proof that the person arriving is connected to it.
There is no universal licence for every garage repair. Check the legal business identity, insurance, relevant manufacturer or technical experience and whether a recognised dispute-resolution code applies. MOT status alone does not endorse all repair work. Check a claimed registration with the issuing body using contact details you find independently. Confirm its scope, status and the individual where the scheme is person-specific. A genuine badge can still be used misleadingly if it covers a different trade or employee.
Ask what public-liability or professional cover applies and request evidence where the job risk justifies it. Insurance is not a competence certificate or automatic dispute guarantee. Look for recent examples involving the same type of fault, property, equipment or material, and ask what went differently on a difficult job.
Read for consistent detail: punctuality, diagnosis, changes to scope, care of the property, final price and response when something went wrong. A perfect score with little narrative is less useful than a mixed but credible history. Check dates and whether the reviewed work resembles yours.
Pause if the provider will not give a checkable identity, claims a credential but discourages verification, quotes an unusually low headline while avoiding the likely total, or insists that a large decision must be made immediately. Category-specific concerns include doing work you did not authorise; using an MOT result to pressure unrelated repairs; replacing parts without showing why they failed; raising the bill substantially without contacting you; using vague diagnostics to justify repeated part changes. None of these automatically proves dishonesty. Ask a direct question and judge the explanation, evidence and willingness to put important points in writing.
The quote should identify the parties, scope, labour, parts or materials, VAT, timing, exclusions, payment schedule, disposal, testing, paperwork and warranty. It should explain how unforeseen work will be approved. If two providers interpreted the brief differently, resolve that difference before comparing totals.
Who will attend and who supervises? What have you allowed for? What is excluded? What could change the price? What evidence will support the diagnosis? When is payment due? What documents and warranty will I receive? Who handles damage, delay or complaint? Ask for answers in writing where they affect the agreement.
A proportionate deposit may be reasonable for ordered materials or reserved time, but ask what it covers and the cancellation terms. Be cautious about large advance payments to an identity you cannot verify. Keep an invoice and payment trail; do not misdescribe a payment at someone else’s request.
Confirm the arrival window, who needs access, what should be moved or protected and who can authorise changes. Record the starting condition with proportionate photographs for higher-risk work. Make sure both sides have the same final scope and contact details. If circumstances on arrival are materially different, revise the agreement before tools, dismantling or treatment begin.
Inspect the result where practical and ask for operation, care or maintenance instructions. Keep certificates, part or material details, waste records, warranties and the final itemised invoice. If something is wrong, notify the business promptly in writing, describe the facts and give a reasonable opportunity to respond where appropriate. Do not let a minor snag become an undocumented argument.
VereLocal profile and verification signals are designed to give you more useful information, not to guarantee a provider, price or outcome. Check what a signal actually covers, review current details and agree the contract directly with the business.
For significant non-urgent work, two or three comparable quotes can reveal differences in diagnosis, scope and assumptions. One careful quote can be enough for a small routine job when identity and terms are clear.
No. Combine review patterns with identity, relevant credentials, insurance, comparable experience, written scope and your direct conversation.
No. A lower price can be efficient and fair. The risk is a price that cannot be reconciled with scope, materials, time or a clear business identity.
It depends on materials and booking commitment. Ask what it covers, when it becomes non-refundable and what happens if the provider cancels.
Use one written brief and compare relevant evidence, scope and total—not badges or price alone.
Search local providers